I’m often tempted to ask Christians who I see praying in public before a meal why they pray. Of course I would never be so disrespectful as to actually walk over and ask. I’m not offended by it, Christians have every right to do it and I support their right. But I do wonder why. So I’ll ask my questions here, where I can safely assume that someone reading a blog about atheism would be amenable to a conversation about faith and belief.
Social Aspects of Praying:
Do Christians feel that God prefers that prayers are said while in a certain posture, with head bowed, eyes closed, and hands clasped? Or is the prayer posture meant more as a performance for the benefit of those around them, rather than for God’s benefit? It seems a lot like the ichthus (fish) bumper stickers – it’s used as a public statement, a testimony. Is the prayer before the meal a polite way of witnessing, a way to show those around them that “I’m a Christian” without actually engaging anyone in conversation? On the one hand, I appreciate that most Christians would be respectful enough not to overtly proselytize those around them. On the other hand, statements to the effect of “I’m a Christian” is not much of a witness. For example, it says nothing about the reality of Jesus which is what a Christian witness or testimony really is. Or possibly, prayer before the meal is a display for other Christians, a way to tell other Christians that you’re one of them – sort of like the Shriner’s “secret” handshake. Maybe it’s both.
Theological Aspects of Praying:
Thank you for this food we are about to receive…
Why do Christians pretend that God gives them their meals? It seems obvious enough where food comes from. The Earth produces food for humans and other terrestrial life. Life on planet Earth has evolved such that there is a food chain. If I may oversimplify a bit just for illustration: plants consume non-living materials like minerals, water, CO2 and sunlight. Animals consume plants, and animals higher on the food chain consume other animals. Humans are near the top of the food chain (yes, we do have natural predators!). Each of our meals has this natural origin. If there is a God, then He doesn’t give us each meal, He gives us the entire Earth from which we get our food. Why not thank God at every meal for the Earth rather than for the meal? The meal seems insignificant relative to the gift of the whole Earth!
Other Quirks Regarding Prayer:
Why pray only for food? Why not pray for water? Water is even more essential to our sustenance than food. We can survive without food for weeks but we can only survive without water for a few days.
Bless this food to our bodies…
“Bless this food to our bodies” isn’t even grammatically correct – the verb “bless” can take the indirect object, “body”. You can bless the food, or you can bless our bodies, but you can’t bless food to our bodies. Nevertheless, this phrase is very wide spread among Christians – try this search on Google (http://www.google.com/search?q=”bless+this+food+to+our+bodies”) and you’ll see what I mean.
My point is not that Christians are guilty of incorrect grammar – we all are. My point is that Christians make this particular grammatical error only in prayers for the meal and not anywhere else. So how does a grammatically incorrect phrase become so popular in prayer and only in prayer? Does it sound more spiritual?
What do you think?
Whether you are Christian or not, what to you think about the Christian prayer for the meal?